Best Mascaras (regular)

Featured Best Mascara

Mascara is a makeup must that many people – even those who don’t regularly use full face makeup – feel they need to wear to enhance their look. For a mascara to earn our highest rating, it must contain most, if not all, of these key features:

  • Quickly enhance lashes, whether from lengthening, thickening, separating, or any combination of these and other features
  • Not smudge, smear, or flake throughout the day
  • Not be overly clumpy
  • Not contain needless irritants

Read more ...

Your results are in the table below. You can narrow your results by using the drop down menus or sort by toggling the column labels. If you would like to add an item to your faves check the box in the "+" column. Click the add to faves button when you're done adding items.

+ Rating Product Brand Category Price Size
Best 3D Extreme Mascara (Discontinued) Revlon Regular Mascara  $8.99
Best Abyssinia Oil Volumising/Strengthening Mascara (Discontinued) Korres Natural Regular Mascara  $20.00
Best Amped Lashes Volume + Defining Mascara Ulta Regular Mascara  $10.00
Best Atomic Volume Mascara (Discontinued) Sephora Regular Mascara  $15.00
Best bareMinerals Flawless Definition Curl & Lengthen Mascara Bare Escentuals (Bare Minerals) Regular Mascara  $18.00
Best bareMinerals Flawless Definition Volumizing Mascara Bare Escentuals (Bare Minerals) Regular Mascara  $18.00
Best Better Than Sex Mascara Too Faced Regular Mascara  $23.00
Best Big Bold Ultra Volumizing Mascara N.Y.C. (New York Color) Regular Mascara  $4.99
Best Bionic Mascara (Discontinued) Smashbox Regular Mascara  $19.00
Best Blueberry Curl Mascara Lumene Regular Mascara  $10.00
Best Bombshell Volume by LashBlast CoverGirl Regular Mascara  $11.99
Best Ceramide Lash Extending Treatment Mascara Elizabeth Arden Regular Mascara  $20.00
Best City Curls Curling Mascara N.Y.C. (New York Color) Regular Mascara  $2.99
Best Colorstay Overtime Lengthening Mascara Revlon Regular Mascara  $7.99
Best Creamy Mascara (Discontinued) Laura Geller Regular Mascara  $15.50
Best Define-A-Lash Volume Mascara (Discontinued) Maybelline New York Regular Mascara  $7.49
Best Definicils High Definition Mascara Lancome Regular Mascara  $27.50
Best DiorShow 360 Mascara (Discontinued) Dior Regular Mascara  $36.00
Best Diorshow Iconic Mascara Dior Regular Mascara  $28.50
Best Doll Eye Mascara Longlash NYX Cosmetics Regular Mascara  $9.50
Best Doll Eye Mascara Volume NYX Cosmetics Regular Mascara  $9.50
Best Double Extend Lash Fortifier & Extender Mascara L'Oreal Paris Regular Mascara  $10.99
Best Double Extend with Lash Boosting Serum Mascara L'Oreal Paris Regular Mascara  $12.99
Best Double Wear Zero-Smudge Lengthening Mascara Estee Lauder Regular Mascara  $24.00
Best Everlong Mascara Lengthening Mascara (Discontinued) Yves Saint Laurent Regular Mascara  $30.00
Best Exceptional Definition Nutrient Enriched Mascara Boots
- No7
Regular Mascara  $7.99
Best Exceptionnel De Chanel Intense Volume and Curl Mascara (Discontinued) Chanel Regular Mascara  $30.00
Best Eye Magnifier Exact Definition Clean Definition Lengthening Mascara (Discontinued) Rimmel Regular Mascara  $6.99
Best Eye Magnifier Eye Opening Mascara (Discontinued) Rimmel Regular Mascara  $6.99
Best Eyes to Kill Exceptional Volume Mascara (Discontinued) Giorgio Armani Regular Mascara  $30.00
Best Eyes to Kill Stretch Lengthening Mascara Giorgio Armani Regular Mascara  $32.00
Best Fabulash Mascara (Discontinued) Revlon Regular Mascara  $6.79
Best Fat Lashes Clinging Silk Tri-Color Mascara Signature Club A Regular Mascara  $16.50
Best Full ’n Soft Mascara Maybelline New York Regular Mascara  $6.89
Best Great Big Lashes Mascara (Discontinued) Paula's Choice Regular Mascara  $9.95
Best Haute & Naughty Lash M.A.C. Regular Mascara  $21.00
Best Hello Lashes 5-in-1 Treatment Mascara IT Cosmetics Regular Mascara  $24.00
Best High Definition Separating Mascara N.Y.C. (New York Color) Regular Mascara  $4.99
Best High Impact Mascara Clinique Regular Mascara  $16.00
Best Illicit Lash Maximum Impact Mascara Paula's Choice Regular Mascara  $11.00
Best Intense i-Color Mascara Volumizing Lash Color (Discontinued) Almay Regular Mascara  $7.99
Best Intense I-Color Volumizing Mascara Almay Regular Mascara  $7.99
Best Lash Act Build & Define Mascara Avon Mark Regular Mascara  $12.00
Best Lash Discovery Mini Brush Mascara Maybelline New York Regular Mascara  $7.29
Best Lash DNA Mascara (Discontinued) Smashbox Regular Mascara  $19.00
Best Lash Doubling Mascara Clinique Regular Mascara  $16.00
Best Lash Extra-Vaganza Quo Cosmetics Regular Mascara  $14.00
Best Lash Love Lengthening Mascara Mary Kay Regular Mascara  $15.00
Best Lash Love Mascara Mary Kay Regular Mascara  $15.00
Best Lash Maxxx 3X Lash Multiplying Effect Mascara (Discontinued) Rimmel Regular Mascara  $7.49
Best Lash Plumper Sephora Regular Mascara  $12.00
Best LashBlast Length CoverGirl Regular Mascara  $7.79
Best LashBlast Volume CoverGirl Regular Mascara  $7.79
Best Lashes to Die For The Mascara Peter Thomas Roth Regular Mascara  $22.00
Best Layer Lash Primer Smashbox Mascara Primers  $18.00
Best Le2 de Guerlain Two Brush Mascara Guerlain Regular Mascara  $37.00
Best Lengthening Mascara (Discontinued) Make Up For Ever Regular Mascara  $19.00
Best Lights, Camera, Lashes! 4-in-1 Natural Mascara Tarte Cosmetics Regular Mascara  $19.00
Best Long Lash Mascara Laura Mercier Regular Mascara  $24.00
Best L’Extreme Instant Extensions Lengthening Mascara Lancome Regular Mascara  $27.50
Best Major Lash Mascara (Discontinued) Stila Regular Mascara  $8.50
Best Marvelous Mineral Mascara (Discontinued) Kiehl's Regular Mascara  $16.50
Best Mascara Perfect Pro Double Protection DHC Regular Mascara  $18.50
Best Mascara Singulier Exaggerated Lashes Dramatic Styling (Discontinued) Yves Saint Laurent Regular Mascara  $30.00
Best Maxi Lash Extreme Volume Mascara (Discontinued) Guerlain Regular Mascara  $28.00
Best Mega Length Lash-Extending Mascara Paula's Choice Regular Mascara  $12.00
Best Noir Couture 4-in-1 Mascara Volume, Length, Curl & Care Givenchy Makeup Regular Mascara  $32.00
Best One Coat Lengthening Mascara Almay Regular Mascara  $5.99
Best One Coat Triple Effect Almay Regular Mascara  $8.19
Best Phyto-Mascara Ultra Volume Sisley Paris Regular Mascara  $65.00
Best Platinum Mascara (Discontinued) Skinn by Dimitri James Regular Mascara  $15.00
Best Pro Lash Mascara (Discontinued) M.A.C. Regular Mascara  $15.00
Best Provocateur 1 Brush, 2 Styles (Discontinued) NYX Cosmetics Regular Mascara  $6.00
Best Runway Length Mascara Victoria's Secret Cosmetics Regular Mascara  $14.00
Best Sin-Full Mascara Kat Von D Regular Mascara  $19.00
Best Sky Rise Lengthening Mascara N.Y.C. (New York Color) Regular Mascara  $1.99
Best Smokey Eye Mascara Bobbi Brown Regular Mascara  $28.00 1.00 tube
Best Soft Lash Mascara (Discontinued) Giorgio Armani Regular Mascara  $29.00
Best SpectacuLash Mascara BeautiControl Regular Mascara  $14.00
Best SpectacuLash Thickening Primer and Maximum Length Mascara BeautiControl Regular Mascara  $12.00
Best Studio Eye Enhancing Mascara e.l.f. Cosmetics Regular Mascara  $3.00
Best Studio Fix Boldblack Lash M.A.C. Regular Mascara  $16.00
Best Studio Fix Lash (Discontinued) M.A.C. Regular Mascara  $16.00
Best Sumptuous Bold Volume Lifting Mascara Estee Lauder Regular Mascara  $24.00
Best Super Magnify Mascara (Discontinued) Avon Regular Mascara  $9.00
Best Telescopic Explosion Mascara (Discontinued) L'Oreal Paris Regular Mascara  $9.49
Best The Colossal Volum’ Express Mascara Maybelline New York Regular Mascara  $7.77
Best The Max Volume Flash Mascara (Discontinued) Rimmel Regular Mascara  $6.83
Best Thickening and Building Mascara (Discontinued) Laura Mercier Regular Mascara  $20.00
Best Visual Effects Curling, Separating, and Lengthening Mascara Lorac Regular Mascara  $20.00
Best Volume Effet Faux Cils Luxurious Mascara for a False Lash Effect Yves Saint Laurent Regular Mascara  $30.00
Best Volume Flash Instant Thickening Mascara (Discontinued) Rimmel Regular Mascara  $7.49
Best Volume Flash Mousse Air-Whipped Volumizing Mascara (Discontinued) Rimmel Regular Mascara  $6.99
Best Voluminous Naturale Natural-Looking Volume & Definition Mascara L'Oreal Paris Regular Mascara  $7.29
Best Volumizing Mascara Mally Beauty Regular Mascara  $20.00
Best Volum’ Express Mascara The Falsies Big Eyes Maybelline New York Regular Mascara  $7.99
Best Volum’ Express The Falsies Mascara Black Drama Maybelline New York Regular Mascara  $6.99
Best Volum’ Express Turbo Boost Mascara 7X Maybelline New York Regular Mascara  $7.77
Best Voluptuous Volume Mascara (Discontinued) Victoria's Secret Cosmetics Regular Mascara  $12.00
Best Wet Gloss Lash & Brow Clear Mascara e.l.f. Cosmetics Regular Mascara  $1.00
Results per page:
Page of 2 Next »
PCWEB-WWW1 v1.0.0.287
Skip to Top of Page
FREE SHIPPING | FREE RESIST Moisturizer with $50 Purchase

Create an Account

Create Account»
  • »

New Customers

You will have the option to create an account after you have submitted your order.