Redness Remedy is a yellow-toned loose powder that is touted as being able to “reduce facial redness on contact and over time.” It fails on both counts. First, this powder is too sheer to counteract redness; you’d have to cake it on to see any sort of camouflaging, not to mention that the yellow tone isn’t going to work on all skin tones without adding a jaundiced appearance over the areas that aren’t red. (This assumes it worked over redness, which isn’t what we found.)
Second, you are not going to see any anti-redness benefit from this powder over time. Although the formula contains some very good anti-irritants, such as licorice and chamomile, the jar packaging won’t keep air out, thus allowing these oxygen-sensitive ingredients to start breaking down once it is opened (see More Info for details).
Furthermore, Bare Escentuals claims that the Redness Remedy is “powered by [their] ActiveSoil Complex,” which is listed as “soil minerals” on the ingredient list. In essence, they are claiming to sell fancy dirt, though “soil minerals” is a recognized ingredient term by U.S. regulatory standards.
There are supposed to be 72 minerals in this soil, but they don’t tell you what the 72 minerals are or what else the soil contains. (Lead and cadmium are minerals present in soil and they’re natural, too, but you wouldn’t want them in abundance on your skin.)Soil also contains a large amount of sand, which has no benefit for skin. Think about this—an acre of soil may contain 900 pounds of earthworms, 2,400 pounds of fungi, 1,500 pounds of bacteria, 133 pounds of protozoa, and 890 pounds of arthropods and algae. It turns out “virgin soil” isn’t really as “pure “as the marketing claims make it sound.
All in all, this is a complete dud!
- Formula doesn’t reduce redness over time.
- Fragrant ingredients can cause irritation (see More Info).
- Too sheer to reduce redness on contact.
- The sole yellow shade won’t work on all skin tones.
- Can give skin a jaundiced look.
- Touted “ActiveSoil Complex,” which is listed as “soil minerals” on the ingredient list, is essentially dirt, and has no skin-care benefit.
Lauroyl Lysine, Water, Soil Minerals, Populus Tremuloides Bark Extract, Nymphaea Alba Flower Extract, Glycyrrhiza Glabra (Licorice) Root Extract, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract, Colloidal Oatmeal, Anthemis Nobilis Flower Oil, Sodium Palmitoyl Proline, Sodium Cocoyl Amino Acids, Sarcosine, Magnesium Aspartate, Potassium Aspartate, Sorbic Acid, Linalool, Butylene Glycol, Limonene, Glycine Soja (Soybean) Oil, Sodium Dehydroacetate, Lonicera Caprifolium (Honeysuckle) Flower Extract, Lonicera Japonica (Honeysuckle) Flower Extract, Lavandula Angustifolia (Lavender) Oil, Lavandula Hybridia (Lavandin) Oil, Mica, Zinc Oxide. May Contain: Iron Oxides
Makeup is what this San Francisco-based cosmetics line is primarily about, and they use the pure and natural marketing angle to entice consumers. The self-proclaimed "healthiest, purest makeup in the world" was founded in 1976 by Diane Ranger, who left the company in the early '90s, and is now run by Leslie Blodgett, who appears regularly on QVC and the company's own infomercials to support and demonstrate her products. Blodgett is largely credited with turning the line she began into a $150 million business—no small feat. The products are sold in most Sephora boutiques and Ulta stores, though the full selection of skin-care products is most often found at the Bare Escentuals freestanding stores scattered throughout the United States.
Supporting the company's portrayal as a leader in purity are the corresponding claims that the bareMinerals makeup does not contain fragrance, oil, binders, preservatives, emulsifiers, or any other harmful chemicals. Although this line does have its advantages for someone with sensitive skin, as it turns out, bismuth oxychloride, a major ingredient in the powder formulations, can cause skin irritation, while the other minerals can be drying (Source: www.sciencelab.com/xMSDS-Bismuth_oxychloride-9923103). Regarding bismuth oxychloride, it is interesting to note that bismuth (a metallic element) seldom occurs in nature. Instead, it is a by-product of copper and lead refining, or is manufactured synthetically. Chemically, it's similar to arsenic, a fact you won't see in any advertising for bareMinerals. However, just as cosmetic-grade mineral oil is not identical to the petroleum from which it originated, neither is bismuth oxychloride identical to bismuth. The bismuth oxychloride used in cosmetics is non-toxic, but this background offers a good example of how skewed a company's definition of "natural" can be.
Aside from the health and purity claims, loose powders are as messy as it gets in terms of your vanity (countertop, not ego) and your makeup bag. The powder just gets all over the place, and the very basic packaging does not do much to minimize the mess. Additionally, while there are softer neutral shades, and some fairly exotic shades as well, most are mildly to extremely shiny and make any amount of crepey skin look more so. The face powder does provide some amount of opaque coverage, but the shine and the thickness can be a bit much. The loose powder eyeshadows and blushes apply in a somewhat lighter way, though they still provide significant coverage. Many women ask me about mineral makeup and whether or not it really is better for skin. The answer to that question is "No."
Although most mineral makeup is innocuous, the texture, appearance, and application have difficulties that make it not comparable to today's best liquid or pressed-powder foundations. We agree with bareMinerals' stance that foundation shouldn't look or feel like a mask, nor should there be a line of demarcation where the application stops. However, their foundations are not the only ones able to achieve this, and there is no inherent benefit to this type of foundation over numerous other options.
There isn't much to say about the skin-care products, but what's worth paying attention to is noted in the At-a-Glance section.
For more information about Bare Escentuals, call 1.888.795.4747 or visit www.bareescentuals.com.