This lightweight serum for the eye area (though there's no reason this couldn't be used all over the face) is essentially a souped-up, better version of Clinique's All About Eyes Serum De-Puffing Eye Massage. It even has the same cylindrical packaging with a metal roller ball applicator that dispenses the product around the eye area. Denese's version is chockfull of antioxidants, skin-identical hyaluronic acid, and anti-inflammatory caffeine. When applied topically, caffeine serves as an anti-inflammatory and has a constrictive effect on skin, which may lead to a reduced puffiness, assuming it arises from edema (swelling) and not aging (Sources: Planta Medica, October 2008, pages 1,548–1,559; and www.naturaldatabase.com).
The main differences between this and the Clinique All About Eyes Serum is that Denese's version contains a much greater amount of the mineral pigment mica. The mica adds shine to the skin, which can have a cosmetic brightening effect, but shine isn't skin care. In addition, Denese omits the fragrant citrus extract that Clinique uses in an amount that's potentially irritating. Yes, you're paying more for Denese's product and you don't get as much product as Clinique provides (0.2 ounce vs. 0.5 ounce) but Denese has the better formula.
Despite the claim of improving dark circles, this doesn't contain ingredients that can do that. However, the barrier repair and antioxidant ingredients will certainly improve the condition of skin anywhere on the face, so in the case of dark circles, you may notice some improvement simply because the skin is in better shape. The anti-puffiness claim is suspect too, unless your puffy eyes are caused by edema (swelling) in which case the massaging applicator and inclusion of caffeine may help. This product cannot address puffiness related to aging, where the fat pad beneath the eye has shifted and skin develops a pooch. This type of puffiness can only be corrected with cosmetic surgery.
Interestingly, one of the plant extracts in this product can cause vasodilation, which means it increases circulation. That can be good but not when dark circles are the concern, at least not if the dark circles are from excess blood vessels underneath skin. Another plant extract in this product has a relaxing action on blood vessels, so most likely the two cancel each other out (Source: www.naturaldatabase.com). Other exotic-sounding plant extracts in this product have no research relating them to skin care, though some such as Bletilla striata (a species of orchid) are a source of fragrance.
One more note: this product does not contain retinol as claimed. However, that doesn't change its status as a very good gel-type serum for all skin types.
An innovative retinol treatment formula that addresses the signs of aging around the eye area. This product helps to soften the appearance of crow’s feet, fine lines, and wrinkles under the eye area. FirmaTone Rx Eye Puff and Circle Minimizer has a unique roller delivery system that gently massages the product into skin.
Water, Glycerin, Butylene Glycol, Pentylene Glycol, Dimethicone, Caffeine, Hyaluronic Acid, Acetyl Octapeptide-3, Glycosaminoglycans, Resveratrol, Magnesium Ascorbyl Phosphate (Vitamin C Ester), Tocopheryl Acetate, Mica, Hydrolyzed Jojoba Esters, Polysilicone-11, Sucrose, Acetyl Glucosamine, Hydroxyproline, Salvia Miltiorrhiza Root Extract, Paeonia Lactiflora (Peony) Root Extract, Ligusticum Chuanxiong Root Extract, Bletilla Striata Root Extract, Camellia Sinensis Leaf Extract, Diospyros Kaki (Japanese Persimmon) Leaf Extract, Carthamus Tinctorius (Safflower) Flower Extract, Lecithin, Titanium Dioxide, Acrylates/C10-30 Alkyl Acrylate Crosspolymer, Sodium Polyacrylate, PVM/MA Copolymer, Nylon-12, Silica, PEG-10 Dimethicone, Isohexadecane, Ammonium Polyacryloyldimethyl Taurate, Potassium Hydroxide, PPG-5-Ceteth-20, Disodium EDTA, Propylene Glycol, Polysorbate 40, Caprylyl Glycol, Phenoxyethanol
This doctor-designed skin-care line was, without question, the one most requested for review by our readers, primarily due to its prominence on QVC's Web site and home shopping program.
A graduate of New York's Cornell Medical College, Dr. Adrienne Denese opened an anti-aging clinic in Manhattan shortly after completing her studies. It has become extremely successful, to the point where she felt it necessary to create her own products to make sure her skin-care advice was being taken.
Her book, Dr. Denese's Secrets for Ageless Skin: Younger Skin in 8 Weeks, on how to take care of your skin, is much like Dr. Perricone's book The Wrinkle Cure, in that both promise to get rid of (or at least really, really minimize) your wrinkles. Another similarity is the lack of supporting research or studies to back up the claims in either book. Neither Dr. Perricone nor Dr. Denese source their information, and more often than not, there are no research reports or supporting studies to be found. We are just supposed to take their word for everything they say. Denese naturally uses her gender more than Perricone to establish credibility and empathy with female consumers (who, no secret, purchase the vast majority of skin-care products out there), and also routinely appears on QVC to discuss her products.
Ironically, her product line, sold exclusively via QVC and Denese's Web site, makes much more sense than a lot of what she writes in her book. After reading the book and evaluating her namesake line, we noted some interesting and frustrating statements and conflicts that deserve attention. One of her statements that we found most surprising, for a dermatologist keen on anti-aging medicine, was: "If a skin-care product doesn't work, it's not the consumer's fault." This statement is not untrue, it's just incomplete. Dr. Denese contends that no one can afford to throw away money on products that don't work, a point with which we truly agree. However, she mentions nothing about carefully establishing a skin-care routine and then following through on it. Unfortunately, many consumers don't follow through, and that's a big reason why they don't get the results they want from products.
For example, using an anti-acne product only occasionally, or not applying sunscreen daily or liberally enough, won't benefit your skin and could easily lead you to believe that the unimpressive results mean the product is faulty.
Moreover, some skin-care problems (like sagging) are beyond what any product can address. (That's why there are dermatologists and plastic surgeons with thriving practices.) All the dermatologists we have interviewed over the years agree that patient compliance with and adherence to skin-care routines and the regimen of topical medications is an ongoing challenge, and there is research supporting that (Source: Dermatologic Therapy, July-August 2006, pages 224–236). Dr. Denese also understands this, as evidenced from her comment about the Dr. Obagi System (for skin discolorations): "The only times I've seen the Obagi System fail is [sic] when patients have skipped steps and ignored instructions."
In another statement Dr. Denese refers to petrolatum and mineral oil as "junk food for skin," stating that "they feel good but they clog your pores." This is not a true statement because neither substance is capable of becoming hard and clogging the lining of the pore. In fact, both of these ingredients have impressive research proving their benefit, mildness, and effectiveness for skin (Sources: Cutis, September 2004, pages 109–116; and Dry Skin and Moisturizers: Chemistry and Function, CRC Press, 2000, pages 252–254).
Petrolatum and mineral oil have greasy textures, so they're not the best-feeling ingredients for someone with oily or acne-prone skin, but in this case greasiness does not equal clogged pores.
Dr. Denese also refers to blackheads as dirt, which is completely false. Blackheads are composed of sebum, dead skin cells, and other debris (mostly tiny hairs) that make up the follicle lining of the pore. The oxidation that occurs as this mixture of sebum and dead skin cells reaches the pore opening is what causes the blackness—it has nothing to do with cleanliness (Sources: Clinical Dermatology, September-October 2004, pages 367–374; Cutis, August 2004, pages 92–97; and American Academy of Dermatology, www.aad.org).
According to Dr. Denese, you cannot exfoliate too much. Yet she doesn't warn against the potential for irritation when too much of a good thing becomes a punishment rather than a benefit, which absolutely can occur with over-exfoliation.
Surprisingly, Dr. Denese does not recommend salicylic acid (BHA) for exfoliation. Instead, she prefers AHAs (glycolic and lactic acids) because AHAs may be used at higher concentrations than BHA. However, the difference in concentrations between AHAs and BHA is not about quantity. Rather, it's because they work best at different concentrations, and also perform differently. That is, a higher concentration of AHA is not more effective or better than a lower concentration of BHA. AHAs are most effective at 5% to 10%, while BHA is most effective at 1% to 2%. In the world of skin care, there are many examples where a higher percentage of an ingredient doesn't necessarily equate with superior effects, as is the case with AHA and BHA (Sources: Women’s Health in Primary Care, July 2003, pages 333–339; Journal of Dermatological Treatment, April 2004, pages 88–93; Dermatology, January 1999, pages 50–53; and Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, April 1997, pages 589–593).
Despite the incomplete information (or in some cases, misinformation) in her book, Denese has crafted some remarkably state-of-the-art products, and the prices, though steep, aren't unreasonable.
As is true for most skin-care lines (including those from dermatologists), there are shortcomings and missteps along with good products here. For those who choose the best of what Dr. Denese has to offer, the rewards will be smiling at them in the mirror each day (but please don't take that to mean your wrinkles will be gone)!
Note: All Dr. Denese products contain fragrance unless otherwise noted.
For more information about Dr. Denese New York, call 866-642-3754 or visit www.drdenese.com.