Kat Von D
True Romance Eyeshadow Palette with Autograph Pencil
Category:Makeup > Eyeshadows > Powder Eyeshadow
Last Updated:11.04.2013
Jar Packaging:No
Tested on animals:No

There is plenty to love about these pressed-powder eyeshadow collections. Each palette includes eight silky, satin-finish eyeshadows and a miniature Autograph Eyeliner pencil.

The eyeshadows come in (mostly) complementary light and dark colors that work well together for creating a variety of eye designs. The rich pigment and the remarkably smooth texture of these fragrance-free eyeshadows make them a pleasure to work with, and propels them to a BEST rating. The formula contains some very good skin-smoothing ingredients, although the antioxidants won't remain stable due to the compact routinely being exposed to light and air. That's OK, though: You can get antioxidants around the eyes from your skin-care products!

Our only complaint is that we'd like to see Kat Von D offer a matte palette option in addition to the satin and shimmer shades. Still, these are quality eyeshadows that offer good coverage that resists creasing even after a full day of wear, plus the shine tends to stay put.

As for the Autograph Pencil, it's a standard, but workable, needs-sharpening pencil, but sharpening is such an annoying step, we always recommend using a twist-up type pencil instead.

Note: There are two versions of the True Romance Eyeshadow Palette; the version without the Autograph Pencil is available for $34. These palettes are not marked as $$$ because each shadow prices out to $4.25—a bargain!

  • Richly pigmented colors provide full coverage and wear well throughout the day.
  • Don't crease or fade.
  • Complementary collection of shades.
  • Smooth, blendable texture is easy to apply.
  • Fragrance-free formula includes a blend of silicones, skin-conditioning ingredients, and a dusting of antioxidants.
  • No matte shades.
  • Autograph Pencil is only average quality.
Brand Overview

Kat Von D At-A-Glance

Strengths: Excellent eyeshadow palettes and trios; long-wearing cream and liquid lipstick; High Voltage Skin eyeshadow primer; Sin-Full Mascara.

Weaknesses: Several pricey products; Tattoo and Dark Circle Eraser is disappointing; Lock-it Tattoo Foundation is average at best, and, unfortunately, is the only foundation option; Autograph Pencil is the only eyeliner pencil, and it’s not worth the money; no powder or blush brushes.

Celebrity makeup lines are nothing new—we’ve seen dozens of them over the years—but this one is a first in that it shocked us a bit, and we are not easily shocked. Kat Von D’s claim to fame is her successful tattooing enterprise, and her role as a former reality TV show star—she also was once engaged to Sandra Bullock’s ex-husband. (You just can’t make this kind of stuff up.) Despite the ups and downs of her back-story, Kat Von D is now a makeup entrepreneur, and a good one.

The line launched in 2007 with only two eyeshadow palettes, cream lipstick, and eyeliner, but since has expanded by adding several new products, including the High Voltage Skin eyeshadow primer and Everlasting Love Liquid Lipstick—both of which received our top rating. Also worth checking out are Sin-Full Mascara and Painted Love Lipstick. Just like most makeup lines, this is one to shop carefully; for every great product, there’s one that underperforms or ends up being a waste of money.

Kat Von D’s line of makeup products is actually quite good for the most part, and far better than we were expecting. This is definitely a brand to consider assuming you’re OK with the prices and the knowledge that in most cases you can find similar and even better options available for far less. (We are not okay with doing expensive when less expensive can knock your socks off!)

All Kat Von D makeup products come packaged with the line’s signature images of roses and thorns (perhaps to reinforce Von D’s love of tattoo design), which definitely makes these products stand out among a sea of blandly packaged makeup containers.

For more information on this brand, go to: www.sephora.com/kat-von-d.

About the Experts

The Beautypedia Research Team is dedicated to helping you find the absolute best products for your skin, using research-based criteria to review beauty products from an honest, balanced perspective. Each member of the team was personally trained by Paula Begoun herself.

Member Comments

No members have written a review yet. Be the first!

Enter a title for your review
First Name, Last Initial
Email Address
How would you rate this product on the following:
500 characters left

Terms of Use

585630-IIS2 v1.0.0.376 3/3/2015 10:48:31 AM