This clay mask also contains peat, which is less appetizingly described as decaying vegetable matter found in marshlands or peat bogs. Peat has no established benefit for skin; we suppose it could be considered a source of plant nutrients, but there are better, fresher ways to get those nutrients directly to the skin.
Lumene claims this mask opens pores (we always thought closing pores was the goal) and deep-cleans the skin, neither of which is true. We find it odd to suggest that the peat gets into the pore because how then are you supposed to get it out? And, physiologically speaking, pores do not open and close like window blinds; they're always "open," because that's how they work to help regulate body temperature.
Although this mask can help absorb excess oil and leave the skin feeling smooth and soft when it's rinsed off, as most masks do, the fragranced formula contains rosemary oil, which is a skin irritant (Source: Chemical Research in Toxicology, November 2001, pages 1546–1551). For this reason and because of the excess fragrance (which no one's skin needs), this mask isn't worth considering.
- Absorbs excess oil without leaving skin feeling tight and dry.
- Contains rosemary oil, a skin irritant.
- Peat isn't a good source of minerals, as claimed.
- Cannot open pores or deep-clean the skin.
Creamy mask absorbs excess oil and impurities from the skin and at the same time tightens the pores. Due to its anti-bacterial properties the mask is perfect for fighting against impurities. Aromatic rosemary opens the pores for the deep-cleansing effect of peat and gives a refreshing fragrance to the product.
Water, Peat, Hydrogenated Polydecene, Kaolin, Glyceryl Stearate, Betaine, PEG-100 Stearate, Sodium Benzoate, Xanthan Gum, (CI 77891), Titanium Dioxide, Potassium Sorbate, Rosmarinus Officinalis (Rosemary) Leaf Oil, Glycerin, Citrus Grandis (Grapefruit) Seed Extract, Disodium EDTA, Alumina, Limonene, Parfum (Fragrance).
The Cosmetics Cop Team strongly suspects that the interest in this product line from Finland is its prestige packaging, coupled with a relatively attractive price point. This is an eye-catching brand that really stands out on drugstore shelves; however, these products aren't really all that inexpensive, especially in comparison to products from Olay, Neutrogena, or RoC. In the United States, you'll find Lumene products at most CVS drugstores as well as at Ulta, Target, and Walgreens. Although the Cosmetics Cop Team loves to find and recommend inspired skin-care and makeup products at reasonable prices, this line isn't one of them.
Two major shortcomings are: (1), the jar packaging, which means any state-of-the-art ingredients in those products won't remain stable once the jar is opened because they deteriorate in the presence of air, and (2), most of Lumene's formulas contain only a dusting of the superstar ingredients they brag about. Vitamin C, ceramides, antioxidants, peptides, and the like are all essential, brilliant ingredients for skin, but when only minute amounts are included, your skin isn't getting much of the good stuff.
What it comes down to is this: Shopping Lumene shortchanges your skin, leaving it needing, and deserving, far better. A bargain isn't a bargain if it isn't the best possible care for your skin. What good is saving money on skin care if your skin is left wanting and, in fact, needing more?
Aside from the jar packaging and the paltry amount of important skin-care ingredients, there are other limitations, adding to this line's woes. If you have acne, skin discolorations, or uneven skin tone, you need to look elsewhere.
From a marketing point of view, Lumene capitalizes on the erroneous notion that age is a skin type, so they group their products according to decades. Complete nonsense! Age is not a skin type, nor is race, height, weight, or ethnic background. Regardless of your age, if you have acne, rosacea, dry skin, oily skin, sun damage, or blackheads, the same ingredients that work for someone in their 30s will work for someone in their 40s, 50s, or 60s. There isn't a single piece of research showing that any specific ingredients or formulations are better for skin depending on your age.
Like a vast number of cosmetics companies, Lumene leads you to believe their products are all natural and loaded with beneficial plant extracts, in this case, from the remote wilderness of Finland. Nothing could be further from the truth. These products are loaded with synthetic ingredients. That doesn't make them inherently bad, it just makes the marketing claims obnoxious and misleading.
For those intent on exploring what this Finnish line has to offer, despite the fact there isn't much here worth your attention, your best bet is to stick with the products for sensitive skin, which are truly fragrance-free, and the cleansers. Oh, and if you want to find out if the cult classic status of Lumene's Blueberry Curl mascara is deserved, look no further: It most certainly is!
One more comment: Many Lumene products contain an extract or oil from the Arctic cloudberry plant. Although there is research proving this plant has anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties, it is far from the only one, and isn't even close to being the best for skin. The fact that Lumene chooses to highlight this plant is about marketing nonsense, because stories sell better than reality. Whether it is from the Amazon, the Swiss Alps, or the Himalayas, geographic location is not what makes a plant extract of any kind superior for skin.
For more information about Lumene, call (888) 253-8916 or visit www.lumeneusa.com.