03.22.2010
1
5
Face in a Case
Rating
$42.50
Category:Makeup > Specialty Products > Specialty Makeup Products
Last Updated:03.22.2010
Jar Packaging:No
Tested on animals:No
Review Overview
Talk about makeup overload! This kit is practically the whole kit ‘n’ caboodle when it comes to color! Housed in a magnetized faux-crocodile leather case are one pressed powder, two shades of concealer, two cream eyeliners, two lip glosses, two shades of powder blush, twelve eyeshadows, twelve lip colors, and three tiny applicators that are as impractical to use as trying to drive a car without a steering wheel. Size-wise, everything is scaled down from what’s normal, but that’s the trade-off for trying to include so much in a palette that’s just slightly larger than a standard checkbook. The pressed powder (best for light skin tones), blushes, powder eyeshadows, and lip colors, which go on surprisingly opaque, are wonderful. The two shades of lip glosses (ivory and fuchsia) are odd choices and a bit on the goopy side, but tolerable, while the cream eyeliners are easy to apply, but don’t last and don’t go on that intensely. The cream concealer is a shea butter–based formula that doesn’t blend that smoothly and tends to crease, not to mention that it’s not much for coverage. Although all of the lip colors are beautiful and the possible combinations practically endless, the eyeshadow collection could do without the purple, blue, and green shades. Luckily, most of the shadow shades are flattering. Face in a Case won’t be every woman’s cup of tea, but if the shades appeal to you and you’re willing to accept that not every product in this palette is superior, then it may be worth purchasing.
Claims
Ingredients
Brand Overview

Skinn by Dimitri James At-A-Glance

Strengths: The toner; a few good moisturizers, including some designed for the eye area (even though skin around the eyes doesn't require a separate product) and for oily skin; the lip scrub; the Nutri-Lift products (even though they don't lift skin in the least); mostly good, and some intriguing, makeup palettes; some great mascaras; the automatic eyeliner pencil.

Weaknesses: No sunscreens (How can you take any cosmetic line's anti-aging claims seriously when they completely overlook the importance of sun protection?); jar packaging for antioxidant-rich products; no products to manage acne or skin.

Dimitri James is a makeup artist, hair stylist, and fashion consultant who spent two decades working for some of the biggest cosmetics companies in the world. After stints with brands such as Estee Lauder and Revlon, he decided, as so many others have before him, to launch his own products. Apparently, he was disenchanted with the business model most large cosmetics companies follow. According to James, the formula was always the same: "make a cheap product, put it in a fancy jar with a nice box and charge as much as possible." His cynical summation is definitely appreciated by those of us on the Cosmetics Cop team. Ironically, however, for the most part, Skinn's business model mimics the business model of many large and small cosmetics companies; that is, his products come in fancy jars, make inane unsupported claims, and are absurdly overpriced. Adding to that insanity, many of his products are poorly formulated.

Aside from the glaring same old, same old mix of disenchantment, those hoping for some good news about Skinn products will be pleased to know that this line does have some products worth considering. That doesn't mean the claims are accurate or that they outperform excellent products from many other lines. Overlooking the omission of reliable sunscreen from this line, the handful of good formulas are capable of getting as close as possible to keeping skin looking youthful and healthy. They won't replace cosmetic corrective procedures, but no skin-care routine will do that. Please refer to the list of strengths for products worth your attention; any products not on that list you can skip, unless you want to set yourself up for disappointment, and you will be disappointed if you expect the farfetched claims to come true.

Skinn's promises for their makeup—that they will make you a picture of airbrushed perfection—are beyond reality. Today's best makeup products can go a long way toward making a beautiful finish to your appearance and they're easier to apply than ever before. Just keep in mind that technique still plays a major role, so don't expect any makeup product to be the final answer. Skinn's color line has just as many misses as hits, so shop carefully. In this case, the foundations and concealer are not worth considering over countless others, but there are some great powder blushes and eyeshadows, a fantastic eye pencil, and mascaras that perform beautifully; but again, these are easily replaced with less expensive options. Those intrigued by makeup palettes may find some good options here, too.

All told, the Skinn line has a handful of impressive products, but it's not remotely "the revolution in cosmetics" Dimitri James makes it out to be. For more information about Skinn by Dimitri James, call (866) 346-4874 or visit www.skinn.com.

Note: This line is sold primarily on home shopping channels.

About the Experts

The Beautypedia Research Team is dedicated to helping you find the absolute best products for your skin, using research-based criteria to review beauty products from an honest, balanced perspective. Each member of the team was personally trained by Paula Begoun herself.

Member Comments
Summary of Member Comments
Results
Value
Recommend
WRITE A COMMENT
Sort by:
Page:
10.05.2013
Great travel item

I bought this kit before going on my big overseas holiday. It was great to have all in one box. Mainly use the eye colours, I have found the colours blend easily. I use the blue/green together to make a smokey grey for evenings. Never bothered with the concealers, rather cakey. Blush colours are good. Best part of the kit is the yellow powder, it was a godsend as it covered my red nose from too much sun and is better then a concealer for dark eye circles. Came with brushes, bonus.

Results
Recommend
Value
Reviewed by
Dianne
WRITE A COMMENT
Enter a title for your review
 
First Name, Last Initial
Optional
Email Address
 
How would you rate this product on the following:
Results
Value
Recommend
     
     
     
Review
500 characters left
 
SUBMIT
CANCEL

Terms of Use

585623-IIS1 v1.0.0.379 3/31/2015 12:26:46 AM