Eye Defining Pencil
Last Updated:09.02.2015
Jar Packaging:No
Tested on animals:Unknown
Review Overview

Of all of Tom Ford's beauty products, this might be the most disappointing. For the asking price, you should get a much, much better product than this!

Eye Pencil is as unremarkable in name as it is in performance. You get a standard wooden pencil that needs sharpening, which means you're wasting product with each turn of the sharpener.

Ford claims this pencil is made with "innovative technology," but never bothers to explain exactly what that technology is or what makes it innovative, or why it's different from any number of similar pencils on the market. And, you certainly won't see that technology in action if you buy it.

Eye Pencil is soft and easy to apply, and the color quality is good, but it smudges as the day wears on. There's just nothing exceptional about it that sets it apart from any number of drugstore products - it's not deserving of your time or your money.

  • Pencil is soft and easy to apply.
  • Color quality is good.
  • Pencil needs sharpening, which wastes product.
  • Liner smudges by the end of the day.
  • Expensive given its average performance.
Brand Overview

Strengths: Fantastic cream lipstick; beautiful eyeshadow palettes; a great brow sculpting product; a unique lip lacquer product; the majority of products are fragrance-free or contain minimal fragrance.

Weaknesses: An eye pencil that's overpriced for its quality; lackluster yet super-pricey foundations, including one with sunscreen that doesn't provide sufficient UVA protection; a mediocre eyelining product; an expensive and ineffective highlighting pen.

Summary: The dashing, debonair Tom Ford is one of the world's hottest fashion designers, famous and sought-after for his controversial photo shoots (featuring models showing more skin than clothes) and his classic, yet edgy, fashion designs. Ford came to prominence in the mid-1990s, when he became Creative Director at Gucci's fashion house. He is credited with bringing glamour back to fashion at a time when grunge and heroin chic looks were en vogue, and he helped take the then-failing Gucci from the brink of bankruptcy to a multi-billion-dollar brand.

A few years after Ford joined Gucci, brand was acquired by rival fashion house Yves Saint-Laurent. Ford became Creative Director there as well. Finally, in 2006, Ford launched his own fashion line of menswear, eyewear, fragrances, and accessories. Five years later, he followed in the footsteps of fellow high-fashion houses Armani and Chanel by launching his own line of color cosmetics.

Housed in sleek black packaging with "Tom Ford" stamped in prominent gold-embossed lettering, the makeup certainly looks luxurious, and the pricing is definitely in the haute couture range - the foundations cost $78! However, like many other fashion designer makeup lines, what's inside Tom Ford's range of products is largely unexceptional, especially given the expense.

Tom Ford's makeup and fragrance lines are owned by cosmetics giant Estee Lauder, so you won't be surprised when we tell you that much of what you see in the Tom Ford line isn't all that different from what other Lauder brands, such as MAC, Clinique, and Lauder's namesake line sell. What that means is you don't need to ante up for Tom Ford makeup, because most of what this line does well is available for less money from other Lauder-owned lines.

High prices aside, though, there are some winners among Tom Ford's small but well-edited makeup line. The lipstick, brow pencil, lip lacquer, and eyeshadow palettes are all high-quality and perform well. We're also pleased to say that most of the makeup products either have no or minimal fragrance, which is always a bonus - especially when you consider that this line got its start in the cosmetics field with perfumes and colognes.

Unfortunately, the foundations feature such ingredients as fragrance and lavender, which are both a problem for skin, and some of the other products, like the needs-sharpening eye pencil, are so common and ordinary that it makes the asking price a joke! Overall, Tom Ford has a handful of excellent makeup products to check out - and the counter personnel we dealt with were first-rate makeup artists – but be aware that you're not getting anything that justifies any of those products' high price tags. If anything, Tom Ford's makeup confirms what we've been saying about cosmetics for years: There are good and bad products in all price ranges, and expensive doesn't necessarily mean better!

For more information about Tom Ford Beauty, visit www.tomford.com.

About the Experts

The new Beautypedia Team proudly and unequivocally maintains the commitment to help you find the best products possible for your skin. We do this by relentlessly pursuing and relying on published scientific research so you will have unbiased information on what works and what doesn't-and the sneaky ways you could be making your skin worse, not better!

The Beautypedia Team reviews all products using the same research, criteria, and objectivity, whether the product being reviewed is from Paula's Choice or another brand.

Member Comments
Summary of Member Comments
Sort by:

Everything written above is true. Smooth and good color, but smudges after a while. Waste of product when sharpening. Many other, cheaper brands would be just as good or better. Not worth the money!

Reviewed by
Enter a title for your review
First Name, Last Initial
Email Address
How would you rate this product on the following:
500 characters left

Terms of Use

585631-IIS3 v1.0.0.431 10/13/2015 9:20:30 PM