(based on 38 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Reviewed by 38 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
(2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
Try a sample first before buying!
from Wheaton, IL
About Me Budget Buyer
Comments about CALM Toner for Normal to Oily Skin - 4 oz:
I am so glad I tried a sample. I am acne-prone, and my face is often sensitive, dry and red due to side effects of prescription Retin-A. I have previously used the Hydralight toner and loved it. I was so disappointed that it was discontinued. The Skin Balancing toner is what I typically use now, and I have been happy with the results. I bought a sample pack of the Calming Toner, thinking that it should better alleviate my morning redness. However, the exact opposite happened! After applying the toner with a cotton ball, my face immediately began to sting. Then, after only a few second, my entire face turned beet RED!! My face has never been so red! Twenty minutes later, it is still red! The toner also has a fishy smell that is unpleasant. I will never use this toner again! My fingers crossed that my face does not break out from this one-time experiment. I will be staying with the Skin Balancing toner. Please Paula, do not continue Skin Balancing the way you discontinued Hydralight! I am so disappointed.
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
(4 of 4 customers found this review helpful)
Test it out first
from Calgary, AB
About Me Brand Buyer
I have very sensitive skin, so when the Calm line came out, it seemed like a god-send. Unfortunately, every product I've tried in this line has made my skin sting a little for a few minutes after application. The Calm Toner, however, made my skin feel like it was on fire. When the burning sensation didn't stop after 10 min, I tried to wash it off, which only made it burn more. It took about 45 min for my face to stop hurting. For the most part, I'd recommend Paula's Choice products to anyone--the skin care routine I've set up with PC products has served me very well. But if you want to try this product, I highly suggest trying a sample of this first.
Please bring back hydralight toner!!!
from Atlanta, Ga
After using the CALM toner and moisturizer, I am now trying to nurse my skin back to health. My chin has completely broken out and my skin looks horrible. I'm not sure why you would discontinue the hydralight line and replace it with something that does the exact opposite of what it claims. Very unhappy. Please bring hydralight toner and moisturizer back asap!!
Only PC Toner that doesn't make my skin sting!
from Chicago, IL
I have very sensitive skin around my eyes and I've tried the skin balancing and hydra light toner both which made the skin around the area sting. Not this one! This instantly calms my skin - I can visibly see redness go away and after 2 weeks of use the tone and feel of my skin has definitely improved.
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
(6 of 7 customers found this review helpful)
Please bring back the Hydralight toner!
from Seattle, WA
I tried this for a couple weeks after losing my favorite toner of all time, the hydralight. This one ended up giving me a few breakouts, rather than calming my skin. I wont be repurchasing and hope that they bring back the hydralight soon!
(8 of 10 customers found this review helpful)
from Los Angeles, CA
I'm here to increase the rating on this product. This product has, over time, significantly improved my oily and rosacea-ridden skin. Paula's whole CALM line is excellent, but I think people get frustrated with it because it fails to deliver significant change quickly, and perhaps people are very attached emotionally to the old Hydralight line. I always felt Hydralight met my needs, but never surpassed them. (I intermittently used the Hydralight cleanser, toner, and moisturizers over the last few years, but only really liked the sunscreen, although I didn't LOVE it.) However each CALM product I've used has delivered healthier, less oily, less irritated skin over weeks of using them. I am on a major budget and can basically only use one product at a time, and chose to buy this one because I wanted something to remove every last trace of dirt/makeup at the end of the day. I am very happy with how much softer and less oily my skin has become over the month I've used it.
Service and delivery comments:
Very quick delivery as always.
(5 of 7 customers found this review helpful)
Not as good as Hydralight
from Danbury, CT
I have normal to oily skin that's also sensitive and suffering from rosacea. I love the Hydralight line and used to use the toner from this line. (I can also use the Skin Balancing Toner in a pinch, but it's not as good as the Hydralight.) This is supposed to replace the Hydralight toner. I am not a fan. This went on burning my face. This, in combination with the lotion from the Calm line caused my rosacea to flare up, adding more redness and new breakouts.
(3 of 4 customers found this review helpful)
So light and soothing
I bought the Calm line for Oily skin. I am combination. This toner is light, gentle and soothing. It doesn't sting. I applied the Calm serum and the Calm Moisturizer for N/O skin after. My face feels soft, balanced, and calm. I really like this little line for sensitive skin. Very nice.
(14 of 15 customers found this review helpful)
from new york
I miss the Clinical Instant Calm Advanced redness relief. My redness was very well controlled with that. I have tried this product over and over again thinking my skin will adjust to but to no luck. Now I walk around with redness on my face :( I have emailed paula's choice customer service asking them bring the old one back since based other reviews and ratings this product is a certain flop. I hope she reads this and I promise I will buy 10 bottles of the old stuff and every month after that!!! so will my friends!!! I don't want to walk around with a red face anymore :(
I love Paula's Products - but NOT Calming Line
By Jen the Sensitive
from St. Louis, MO
I am a Paula-addict, and have extremely sensitive skin so was eager to try the calming line, but this had the exact opposite effect! This toner actually inflamed my skin and it took several weeks to recover! The skin balancing line is still my favorite and that toner does not irritate my skin at all!
Learn More >