(based on 34 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Reviewed by 34 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
(2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
Smudges on me
from Lawrence, KS
About Me Beauty Conscious
Comments about ENDLESS LASH Mascara - Black:
I bought this a while back when there was a sale as a replacement for the Mega Lash from Paula's Choice I'd been using. I finally tried the Endless Lash a couple of weeks ago and have been so disappointed to find it smudges badly on me. I end up with raccoon eyes every time I wear it. I have mild dry eyes, which makes them sensitive and prone to slight watering. I'm not talking tears running down my face, just more blinking and maybe a tiny bit of moisture migrating to my lashes. The now discontinued Mega Lash held up to watery eyes beautifully--not waterproof, but nicely water resistant. (Heck, I even cried in it and it held up.) I never had under-eye smudges when I wore it. But the Endless Lash is unwearable for me. I can't get through the day without big smudges under my eyes every time. For reference, I wear powder Other than that, it's a decent mascara. Nothing extraordinary or unusual. It washes off easily with regular face wash. Paula's Choice mascaras have tended to be wetter formulas than is my preference, requiring more "working" and careful non-blinking brushing through while it dries. I managed to make the Mega Lash work for me and the payoff of no smudges all day was worth it. But the Endless Lash is sadly a no-go for me. My quest continues for a mascara that is water resistant without the difficult removal of a true waterproof.
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
Absolutely perfect! Long beautiful lashes that last all day. Thanks for another great product that I can't be without.
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Black as night
from Chicago, Illinois
About Me Minimalist
I had been using the maybelline sensational lash mascara for three months and because my eyes are very sensitive it was time to get a new mascara. I had tried the other two paulas choice mascaras before but they were way too natural for me and didn't give me enough volume. This one however is perfect. It is blacker than any i've ever used before and you get a lot of product for your money. The one thing is that the brush does require a learning curve, it doesn't really help you apply at all whereas other mascaras have little hooks and are shaped to your eye so that you don't have to work as hard. This one is very soft with almost no bristles so it really comes down to how amazing the formula is. However I don't get this on my eyelids or undereyes when i apply it so I'm fine with the brush. It stayed on all day but didn't force me to scrub my eyes to remove it. Love this!
Pretty Darn Good
I have tried many different mascaras looking for "the one". This is as good as any I've tried. It gives me beautiful dramatic lashes, doesn't dry out, doesn't smudge or flake, and is long lasting. It mostly comes off with soap and water. I simply finish with a swipe of eye make up remover to get the job done.
(3 of 3 customers found this review helpful)
Not The Same Quality as Fantastic Lash
from Las Vegas, NV
The Fantastic Lash, made in Poland, stays on all day. No flaking, NO residue on eyelid, etc. The product lasts a very long time for mascara. The ENDLESS Lash rubs off/flakes off and is no where near as long lasting as Fantastic Lash. I am back to Fantastic Lash!
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Good but not perfect
from Little Rock, AR
Mascara works great. Great color, stays without smudging. Contrary to others, I have no problem removing it. My complaint is it comes out of the tube with too much mascara on the wand. You have to wipe a ton of mascara off before you can use it.
(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
from Morinville, Alberta
I LOVE LOVE LOVE this mascara! It did not irritate my eyes and did not have the typical mascara smell :) The brush is a bit weird, not really how it looks in the picture, but it does the job. It was hard to get off after it dried with a q-tip (the extra i got on my eye lid) which says something about the staying power! I WILL be buying this again and will probably be my GO TO mascara! Thank you
This is my main mascara now, so easy to put on and I only need one or 2 coats, thought I would end up hating the brush but surprisingly it works so well, very little clumping and spreads out lashes well. I wear it all day even to the gym doing heavy weight lifting and not a smudge or flakes.
Difficult to remove with soap & water
from Sacramento, Ca
I like the fact that it defines lashes with minimal clumping. However, I feel that it isn't easily removed with soap and water, especially under the eyes. I had to use special eyelid cleanser twice, with a bit of rubbing, to get it completely removed. So even though I liked the look of my lashes with this mascara, I will go back to my Clinique High-Impact mascara, which is more easily removed without so much effort.
(1 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
Smudges too easily
By KC in SC
from South Carolina
About Me Classic Style
I wanted to love this mascara. It goes on smoothly and looks great when first applied, natural and not too heavy. Unfortunately it smudged and left dark circles under my eyes. Really disappointing. I like how it goes on more smoothly than the MegaLength mascara but I didn't have problems like this with MegaLength. Good idea, just not worth looking tired an hour into the day.