(based on 81 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Reviewed by 81 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
from st paul
About Me Natural Style
Comments about FANTASTIC LASH Mascara - Black:
I hate this garbage-the mascara clumps on the plastic wand. While Paulas Choice makes excellent skin care products-the make-up line is in general awful.
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
It Has Changed
About Me Classic Style
This used to be my most favorite mascara, but it is now messy and goopy right out of the tube. I purchased a new one hoping that it was just the tube, but it is the same and the brush is coated with gobs of mascara and my eyelashes look ridiculous!! Will try the other one, but I might have to go elsewhere, and I don't want to
A little disappointing
from North Carolina
My complaint with this product is the brush, and how it dispenses. When I remove the brush from the tube, there is ALWAYS a lot of excess product on the brush and the stick that the brush is attached to. It's gloppy and I have to wipe it before I can use it. The brush isn't a brush, it's plastic spikes. I know that's popular in mascara brushes but I find it very hard to use - they make my lashes clump together rather than separate and again dispense too much product. The mascara itself is pretty good once I've cleaned the wand, applied it and then used another brush to remove excess and try to separate my lashes. I really liked the previous mascara that I had from Paula's Choice (MegaLength Lash Extending) but it doesn't seem to be available anymore.
Images shared by AnotherPaula
Excess product removed.
Tags: Using Product
(3 of 3 customers found this review helpful)
My new favorite!!
from St Louis, MO
WOW! This was my first impression of this fabulous mascara. First of all, I love the brush - that is what initially convinced me to try this product, because of its similarity to another of my favorite & more expensive mascaras. Well Fantastic Lash blew my former fave right out of the water! Not only is it easier to apply, but it doesn't flake, and is easier to remove! The brush is wonderful for separation and definition of individual lashes, and it gives length for days! And the price can't be beat. Definitely my new favorite mascara.
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
(2 of 3 customers found this review helpful)
Gloppy and messy
from Knoxville, TN
I needed more mascara after running out of the MegaLash mascara by Paula's Choice. II decided to try this. Very disappointed. The mascara collects in glops around the top of the tube and completely coats the brush. I have tried cleaning the tube opening and the brush. No luck. Applies in glops and bonds lashes together. Please, PC, being back the MegaLash mascara!
(1 of 5 customers found this review helpful)
lasted one week
from kahului, hi
About Me Beauty Conscious
I loved previous mascara, amazing product but, for some reason discontinued right now. Fantastic Lash Mascara was Ok for about a week and after became really massy. Sending it back.
Clumpy and Gooey
By joeys' aunt
from punta gorda FL
About Me Minimalist
I bought this mascara based on the reviews. It was okay for the first week, but then it became gooey and clumpy. I wiped the wand to remove excess product, but as soon as I put it back in the package it came out gooey again. It's not worth sending it back. Just a live and learn experience. P.S. I've been using the PC MegaLength Mascara which is wonderful, but no longer available.
(5 of 6 customers found this review helpful)
Disappointed in this mascara!
By Ann Y
from South Florida
I love all my Paula's Choice products EXCEPT FOR THIS ONE. This mascara is flaky and makes me feel like I have something in my eye. It does not stay in place and smears above and below my lashes for a couple hours after I apply it.
(0 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
Love, Love, Love
from North Central USA
Used on upper lashes, not confident enough to ditch my waterproof product on the lower lashes. Love the applicator and ease of application. Love the look of the results!
(5 of 5 customers found this review helpful)
from Portland, OR
I really like this mascara. I was initially concerned if I would like the wand, but I'm happy to say it's probably the best mascara wand I've ever used. It allows for easy coverage and lengthens lashes.