(based on 75 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Reviewed by 75 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
Clumpy and Gooey
By joeys' aunt
from punta gorda FL
About Me Minimalist
Comments about FANTASTIC LASH Mascara - Black:
I bought this mascara based on the reviews. It was okay for the first week, but then it became gooey and clumpy. I wiped the wand to remove excess product, but as soon as I put it back in the package it came out gooey again. It's not worth sending it back. Just a live and learn experience. P.S. I've been using the PC MegaLength Mascara which is wonderful, but no longer available.
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
Disappointed in this mascara!
By Ann Y
from South Florida
I love all my Paula's Choice products EXCEPT FOR THIS ONE. This mascara is flaky and makes me feel like I have something in my eye. It does not stay in place and smears above and below my lashes for a couple hours after I apply it.
(0 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
Love, Love, Love
from North Central USA
About Me Beauty Conscious
Used on upper lashes, not confident enough to ditch my waterproof product on the lower lashes. Love the applicator and ease of application. Love the look of the results!
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
(3 of 3 customers found this review helpful)
from Portland, OR
I really like this mascara. I was initially concerned if I would like the wand, but I'm happy to say it's probably the best mascara wand I've ever used. It allows for easy coverage and lengthens lashes.
(1 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
Not my favorite
from New England
I'm a big Paula's fan, but this mascara is not my favorite. I felt this was thick, heavy and clumpy on application. I like a more natural looking mascara - this made my lashes look overly made up. For me, Paula's other mascaras are far better than this.
from Raleigh, NC
This is the mascara I've always been looking for!! No black smudges under my eyes at the end of the day, but it's not waterproof so it comes right off when I wash my face before bed. Love!!!
(5 of 5 customers found this review helpful)
#1- BEST MASCARA I HAVE "EVER" USED
from Las Vegas, NV
Prior to this Fantastic Lash Product and it's predecessor, my daughter and I had to purchase mascara every 3-4 weeks. It would dry out/run out. This mascara not only goes on nicely, lasts all day (and night), doesn't flake/rub off but one tube lasts the longest I have ever seen. I am 51 years old and this is the first mascara I have found I can wear every day, all day, in any weather. It is safe/comfortable with contact lenses too.
Doesn't clump, smudge and it's easy to remove
By Marley's Mom
from Greenville, SC
This product is awesome and is priced quite reasonably. I have tried lots of different mascaras over the years with mostly unimpressive results. This one delivers. My only request is that it be offered in BROWN! As a redhead, black is too harsh. Thanks
(5 of 6 customers found this review helpful)
Best mascara ever
from So. Cal
This is undoubtedly the best mascara I have ever used. I'm in the 'older' crowd so I've had a lot of experience trying different products. Normally I have short, stubby, not particularly thick lashes. I will say I use Latisse to lengthen my lashes now. But, that being said, this mascara thickens, lengthens and separates beautifully. No clumping either! It doesn't smudge even though use a moisturizing sunscreen and eye cream during the day (both are PC products). At night it removes easily with my normal eye make up remover pads. For me, there just isn't anything not to like about this mascara.
from Houston, TX
About Me Classic Style
This mascara is very basic. It will add nice length and definition, although the formula was a bit wet and did tend to clump the lashes together a bit. I didn't think that this mascara provided any volume to my lashes. I received this mascara at no additional cost with another order, and I don't think this was a waste as this is a nice everyday mascara that I can wear to work. I only gave it three stars because it did smudge on my lower lash line and I could easily find a very similar (or better) mascara from the drugstore. Love Paula's Choice overall, just didn't love this.