(based on 160 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Reviewed by 160 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
Didn't Work For Me - Puffy, Red, Irritated Eyes
By No Nickname
from Anaheim Hills, CA
About Me Minimalist
Comments about GENTLE TOUCH Makeup Remover - 4.3 oz:
I had been using plain ol coconut oil to remove my eye makeup. However, I didn't like the oily feel it left and the way my vision would sometime become blurred for a while. I decided to try this product because of all the great reviews - it seemed like it was extra gentle and easy to use. I used this product to remove my eye makeup on a Friday evening, went to bed & woke up to the most puffy, red, irritated skin around my eyes. It took three days to recover from the irritation. During those three days, the skin around my eyes continued to be itchy, red and the inside of my eyelids burned so much it was hard to sleep. I had to just let it heal - while it was healing, the skin started to flake off - it was almost like a burn healing. I am now able to put a bit of moisturizer around my eyes to soften the roughness the burn left. I will be contacting Paula's Choice and returning this product. I guess I'm going back to good ol' Coconut Oil.
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
(2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
The Best Makeup Remover Ever!
from Ogden, UT
About Me Beauty Conscious
I have tried all types of makeup removers and I'm in love with this one! I can put it all over my eyes with no irritation. It is smooth on the skin not drying, no alcohol, no smell. All I ask is for a bigger bottle please. :)
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Best makeup remover I've ever tried!
from Hollywood FL
About Me Beauty Expert
Removes all traces of makeup, not greasy, lightweight. Easily the best makeup remover I've ever tried. Would recommend this to everyone :)
(6 of 8 customers found this review helpful)
The best remover for sensitive eyes
from Plano, TX
About Me Brand Buyer
WOW! I wear only waterproof eye makeup and this gets it all off with very little effort. I used it for the first time tonight with my sensitive eyes, and my contacts in! By far the gentlest and most effective I've used. I just started using Paula's line and I've been impressed with everything, but this is holy grail status.
Takes my puffiness out!
from Sterling, VA
About Me Budget Buyer
I use this product every night to remove my makeup. I absolutely love it. I feel like I'm really treating my eyes and face well by using this product. It's so great it actually takes the puffiness out of my eyes after using--so whatever is in this, please put in an eye cream!!
(6 of 7 customers found this review helpful)
Wonderful eye makeup remover
By Sarah S.
This makeup remover works wonderfully. I just ordered my second bottle before I could run out of the first one I decided to try. This is the only eye makeup remover that I have found that does not make my eye area sting, or make my vision fuzzy after use. I have very sensitive skin around my eyes. It takes off my eye shadow, eyeliner, and waterproof mascara quickly and easily. I will definitely be a repeat customer for this product.
(1 of 4 customers found this review helpful)
By Dawn Woodruff
from Knoxville, TN
I use this product before I cleanse my face. It does a wonderful job of removing my waterproof eyeliner and mascara. I love how it's fragrance free and doesn't irritate my skin like other eye makeup removing products. My skin doesn't feel super oily after using it.
(3 of 3 customers found this review helpful)
Best Makeup Remover
from Seattle, WA
It is so much better than the Clinique one I used before. It does not irritate my eyes and I can remove makeup easily.
(7 of 8 customers found this review helpful)
My favorite all time make-up remover
from San Francisco
Perfect for removing my eye make-up and using it on my complicated skin condition.I stopped using other brands' make-up removers because this is just the best product for me.
(4 of 4 customers found this review helpful)
Hands down the best remover of makeup
from WA state
Between all family members I think we use almost every PC product available and I can't believe I hadn't tried this before. I've been using the wipe style because they are so convenient for what I need them for which is travel and on the go. My young daughter is a dancer and man alive we have some makeup to put this to the test. it requires absolutely no rubbing. All that waterproof stuff just melts instantly. I've handed this out to other moms and they are quick sold. It's totally non-irritating which is my number 1 concern with kids and teens.