I loved Paua's products but this one was a disappointment. This product did not work for me. I do not have full eyebrows. I needed a an eye brow color that would fill in and add to my eyebrows. This does nothing. I would not recommend it. Sorry.

I've always used waxy eyebrow pencils to fill in my brows. I wasn't sure what this Browlisitc eyebrow color was about, but since I knew Paula makes great products and she totally honors her satisfaction guaranteed policy I gave it a try. I love it!! It goes exactly where I need it to go. It dries very quickly and stays all day even through exercise. I love it! Thanks Paula for changing the way my skin and make up look!!

I reviewed Browlistic 2 weeks ago and was loving the product, however, in that short period of time...I've all but run out of product! What was a first, a quick swipe across my brows has now become a hit or miss that anything will come out of the tube. Disappointed with the quantity in the pen.

Love the concept and precise pen-like format, but this just wasn't pigmented enough to show up on my darker brows, so this was one of the very few PC products that didn't work for me. I've seen other reviews of people using this as an eyeliner, but I didn't find it was pigmented enough for that either (I always use dark brown/black liners). If there is ever a Dark Brown shade option added, I would definitiely rethink trying this again.

This is the best brow product I've ever used—and it costs much less than the competitors. Some of the hairs on my brows are very light and I'm able to almost "color" them so the show up. It's also very easy to fill in sparse sections on my brows and they look very natural.

I have finally found an answer to my sparse brows!! I've tried all of the popular products on the market for brows...some cost me a small fortune with no real return. But this little beauty takes the prize! My brows finally look real and not painted on! LOVE IT!! I have medium brown hair and brows. I ordered the light brown and it matches perfectly.

I really liked this when I first received it. Shortly after, it became hard to get any product to come out. I tried washing the brush, but it didn't help. Trying it a second time....

This is a fantastic product ! It is very easy to apply but what I love most is that it does not leave visible fibres behind on the skin. With most ordinary pencils you can see the bits and pieces of flaky product sitting on your skin like tiny little "crumbs". Not with this product ! Even from close-up the look is clean. I just wished Paula would make an eyeliner in a similar manner or bring back a more emollient version of her now obsolete gel eyeliners, the colours of which were great !

I searched for years for a product that fills in sparse eyebrows. There are tons of brow tints on the market, but brow fillers are rare & cost twice as much as this one. This blends perfectly with my brows (I am a medium blonde and use the light brown) and once it sets, it goes nowhere, even using a brow tamer on top of it. Easily one of the most essential make up products I have ever used. Thank you, Paula!

I love the natural way this product looks when I put it on. It has a tip like a fine brush-tip felt pen, so it's easy to control the thickness of the lines. I have medium brown hair with highlights the color of brushed brass and the light brown shade blends in nicely with my very light brown brows, while making them more visible and giving them more definition.

I would like to express how much i'm liking this product. It looks natural and doesnt itch..It does stay on when i accidentally touch my eyebrows. Very Very impressed

And to think I spent double on one from Anastasia Beverly Hills...! I have fair skin and dye my hair red, although my eyebrows are dark blonde/light brown. The Light Brown shade has been perfect for me. Enhances my brows just right. I use it in combination with Anastasia's brow powder and set everything with clear brow gel. I LOVE THIS PRODUCT.

Love this brow pencil. Stays on well, only reapply every couple of days. Does not dry out. Thanks, Paula and team for a great product!

Better than a pencil, not as harsh. You can gradually build the color. Not very good on covering grey, however. I have light brown eyebrows and I use the light brown. I bought the darker brown but it was way too dark.

Love, Love, Love!!!!!! I find other brow liners turn grey on me. This stays perfect all day long! Cannot live without!!!!

I really love this brow pencil, it goes on so naturally, the sable color is perfect for me. My main and only complaint is that it ran out after just a few weeks! I definitely want more, but spending over $10 a month on a brow pencil is kind of hard on the budget.

I have been using this product for almost 2 years. I had a medical issue in which I lost all hair on my brows. This pen worked fine for the first year and half. But I did have the issue that it ran out in a month's time which was frustrating. I always have to order multiple pens. The last two pens I have used do not seem to have the coverage that prior pens had. I have to go over the brown area too many times to have it be effective. I believe this product has changed over the past year. Customer Care Response: Thank you for your review! We are sorry to hear about your experience with the Browlistic Pen and will be sure to forward your feedback along to our Product Development Team. Please contact customer care so that we may offer you an in house credit for the product. Also, feel free to check out: Beautypedia for other brow options you may try. Please contact customer care with any questions, we are happy to help!

I have black eyebrows, but I understand that defining brows heavy-handedly with black can look overdone and kabuki-like. That said, this product is too transparent for my needs. I have to keep layering in order to even get a natural look, and any kind of edge definition is out. For me, the best look comes from a very light-handed application of a dense but natural color (Recently I like L'Oreal's Lacquer Liner in Dark Slate). This approach requires more artistry and delicate brush work, but I've been doing my makeup for 30 years now. I think I can hack it. I preferred Paula's discontinued liner in the pot (though it dried up quickly, and I don't believe there was a good taupey option). If she comes out with something similar in the future, I'll definitely give it a go. I won't reorder this, but I'll keep it around and use it up. This is probably an okay option for people with lighter eyebrows. And if you haven't developed the skills to use a denser product, do yourself a favor and stick with this one. When it comes to brows, it's better to underdo it than overdo it. Customer Care Response: Thank you for your review! We are sorry to hear about your experience with the Browlistic and will be sure to forward your feedback along to our Product Development Team. Please contact customer care so that we may offer you an in house credit for the product. Also, feel free to check out: Beautypedia for other brow options you may try. Please contact customer care with any questions, we are happy to help!

I'm Asian with black hair, so it's very difficult for me to find eyebrow colors that match. The medium brown matches perfectly- neither too brown nor too dark/black. Also, it's very easy to use since the color comes out light and diffused. There are only a couple drawbacks that I can think of. One is that it seems to run out fairly quickly. Another is that it's not really that useful if you need to draw in only one or a few tiny lines/hairs, since the brush is more soft instead of stiff. Maybe a two-sided pen, with the addition of a stiffer brush to draw finer lines would be a good idea. For now, I use another brow pen for that, but the colors don't match exactly and it's a hassle having to buy two different brow pens. Customer Care Response: Thank you for your review. We will be sure to pass your feedback along to Paula and her Product Development Manager. In the meantime we are happy to send you a complimentary Browlistic Precision Brow Color. If you have any questions or concerns please contact customer care and we are happy to help!

I really love this product. It looks so natural, no red tint at all, which I've found is the downfall to most brow pencils and markers I've tried. I only wish that it lasted longer! It applied great for about a week, after that it began to dry out somewhat drastically even though I made sure to replace the cap tightly each time I used it. If I store it upside down the color flows more fluidly for awhile, but overall the consistency isn't great, and I have to apply several layers to get the amount of color I want. Other than that, the product is very nice. Customer Care Response: Thank you for your review. We will be sure to pass your feedback along to Paula and her Product Development Manager. If you have any questions or concerns, please contact customer care, we are always happy to help.

Perfect! Stays all day and matches my brows exactly! I've always had a problem finding anything to fill in my brows that looks natural on me because I'm a natural blonde with brown eyebrows. The light brown shade of this, in my opinion, goes on with a mix of blonde and brown in it. Perfect for me!

addendum to my last review entry, actually, another REQUEST:Can you make an eyeliner similar to this pen? maybe a slightly stiffer brush? same long wearing power? Customer Care Response: Thank you for your review! We will be sure to pass your feedback along to Paula and our Product Development Team. If you have any questions please feel free to contact customer care anytime, we are always happy to help!

I bought, I tried, I LOVE! I have other brow markers which I also really like and this is right up there with the $20+ ones. I have not yet used up a pen, and I've been using it about 4x a week for 2 months now. I have sparse brows and need this to create shape and color and it delivers. It starts off light and you can build up the concentration of color by going over the same spot until you are happy with the color. It is oil resistant, as I have very oily area near my brows and it stays all day until I am ready to remove it with my skin balancing PC cleanser. One suggestion for Paula is to add another, DARKER shade. Thanks for a great product!

This stuff is fantastic! I have strawberry blonde hair and even lighter eyebrows. I always use this color to lengthen my brow and fill it in before using the blonde brow color wand to color the hairs. It lasts all day and looks totally natural. I recently died my hair dark and am still able to use this brush to thicken up my eyebrows so they don't disappear. This is an essential tool in my makeup case!

I love my eyebrows and have always tried to keep them shaped and looking natural. When I tried this product I realized how natural really should look. I thought because my brows were so dark that I should always use dark eyebrow pencils, but the medium brown looks natural and better than I could have imagined. The product applies very well, even though my brows are very thick with small bald spots, I can get the product just where I want it. I like the accuracy and the brush tip. Thank goodness Paula knows what she is talking about and is there to help us out! I thank you (and my eyebrows thank you) Paula!