I've tried dozens of concealers for under-eye circles, and while this one isn't as bad as most, it isn't as good as I expected it to be after reading the description. I was a bit surprised and disappointed that this didn't do it for me. It goes on much drier and thicker than I had anticipated. The finish looks cakey and thick rather than "skin-like" as the description claims. I tried several different application and skin-prepping techniques, but none improved the results, unfortunately.

This is the best concealer I've ever tried! It's easy to apply and lasts all day (except every now and then on my nose). It covers my super dark circles and redness on my nose. It also doesn't irritate my eyes. Best I've tried so far!

Non-irritating, fragrance free, and no animal testing, otherwise all other claims are totally wrong. It was actually one of the worst concealers I've ever used on my 50+ year old skin. I've ordered a number of things and am extremely happy with them but this one, not so much.

I was excited when I purchased Paula's concealer, however was disappointed when I use it. It when on smoothly when applied. I even warmed it up between my finger tips to make it more pliable. It didn't take long before it looked chalky and became flakey. I'm glad I didn't pay a lot for this product. I won't be ordering it again.

I am a makeup artist and have tried a multitude of concealers, including the Amazing Cosmetics concealer, "the gold standard". Paula's Choice beats it! I have both colors and that is enough for any skin tone that I am challenged with. It applies easy, builds easy for more coverage, has a wonderful finish and stays all day. It is just the right consistency... and the amount of product for the price is a STEAL. I recommend this concealer to all my clients!

I wish I liked this!I love Paula's products and only use her products for skin care.Ijust decided to try some of her cosmetics and was very disappointed in this concealer.While the color is perfect, the texture is very dry and for my 40+ year old skin- I in no way want my under eye area to look dryer. This concealer totally highlighted the wrinkles and made them look worse then without make up.Please offer a truly "creamy" concealer as this one was advertised as!!!! Loved the mascara & brow pen!

I was so looking forward to getting this concealer because of it's good reviews, but I should have payed more attention to the mediocre reviews. I got this concealer for dark circles under my eyes because the description said that it doesn't settle into wrinkles around the eyes, but it does settle into the wrinkles. Also, the description says that it won't cake, but it sort of does. I have some small acne scars on my chin, and the concealer settled into them and made my chin look really gross.

I use the soft ivory as an eyeshadow primer/concealer on my eyelids and undereye area, and then use the soft neutral for overall facial spot concealer. I've tried many concealers...Exuviance, Dermablend, Benefit, Lancome...would put this concealer right up with the best of them, or better. I like the creamy, yet firm consistency because it blends nicely, but doesn't cake and stays put throughout the day. I do use a final sweep of pressed powder to set the concealer. Works beautifully!

I use the soft ivory as an eyeshadow primer/concealer on my eyelids and undereye area, and then use the soft neutral for overall facial spot concealer. I've tried many concealers...Exuviance, Dermablend, Benefit, Lancome...would put this concealer right up with the best of them, or better. I like the creamy, yet firm consistency because it blends nicely, but doesn't cake and stays put throughout the day. I do use a final sweep of pressed powder to set the concealer. Works beautifully!

I REALLY like this website for the cheap samples as i'm on a budget and do not like spending money on products i don't see. Please make a sample for this as i don't know which skin tone/ if i like it! thank you!!! :) Customer Care Response: Thank you for the suggestions, we will certainly pass along your comments and feedback! All our products have a 60 day guarantee so you may certainly try the product and if you are not happy with it return it for a full refund, exchange, or in house credit. Please contact customer care with any questions.

Excellent concealer and easy to use. Very natural looking!! I've used some that caused my eyes to tear but this caused no irritation at all.

I tried this in hopes it would be a good concealer however it went on way too thick and wasn't light enough for me. It may be good for spot coverage but I like to use a concealer under my eyes, beside my nose and on some red spots. Might be good for some but I'm in my 30's and it created kind of like small wrinkles under my eyes that aren't there when I'm not smiling normally. Customer Care Response: We're sorry you were not happy with this concealer; you are welcome to check out Paula's suggestions at Beautypedia to see if you find a concealer that works better for you. In the meantime we will leave an in house credit for the product on your account which may be used on a future phone order but cannot locate this product on your account. Please contact customer care so that we may locate this product on your account. We will track your comments with our Product Development Manager & Paula. Please contact customer care with any questions, we are happy to help.

I have tried many of the very expensive concealors but Paula's is the absolute best! It goes on easy with finger application and is moisturizing. It doesn't dry out throughout the day like others do. It doesn't settle into wrinkles throughout the day! I find the trick is to not use too much. I also put a light layer of coconut oil on first, let it sit, then apply the concealor. My only wish is that there was a darker colour than Neutral as Neutral is a little too light with a tan in summer.

I bought the Ivory shade which matches my NC15 skin shade perfectly. The texture however dried flaky and made the area just crispy looking. My undereye and inner eye corner have never been a dry skin area for me, and no concealer has ever done this to me. It's not worth the cost for me to return so hopefully I'll figure out a different use for it. Not even going to attempt to use as a lid primer, can't imagine how that could work. Also the hinge feels very flimsy and breakable. I love most of Paula's products, but why why why is the packaging consistently poor? It cannot be price, ELF has better packaging for Pete's sake! I'm really sad because the color was so perfect. Customer Care Response: Thank you for your review. We are sorry to hear the product did not produce favorable results for you. The truth is that skin care is tricky. Each person will potentially respond different to products. You are welcome to check out Paula's suggestions at Beautypedia to see if you find a concealer that works better for you. We will certainly pass along your comments and feedback about the texture and packaging to Paula. In the meantime we will leave an in house credit for the product on your account which may be used on a future phone order. Please contact customer care with any questions, we are happy to help.

This concealer did not blend easy for me. It actually highlighted my wrinkles and looked cakey. Will not purchase again. Hopefully, PC comes out with a concealer in a tube instead. Customer Care Response: Thank you for your comments. We will be sure to share your feedback with Paula and her Product Development Manager. They do take customer feedback seriously. Please know we do have our 60 day return policy if a product does not work for you. You can also check out www.beautypedia.com to search reviews of other product brands! Please contact customer care with any questions or concerns, we are happy to help.

My absolute favourite concealer. I use it on blemishes, under eye circles and sun spots. Does not dry out and crack like some brands. My only complaint would be that it can be smudged off it not sealed with a powder. Love it.

I really like this concealer. It goes on like silk and I appreciate that the color is not yellowish. The soft ivory works very well on my fair skin. It covers all my imperfections beautifully. The only reason that I'm giving it 4, not 5 stars, is because I needed to use a finishing powder to set it, or else it didn't last.

I love most of Paula's products and recommend them to everyone. However, this concealer is not one of them. Once I put it on under my eyes, it not only settles into creases, but it flakes and balls on my skin. Not sure what that is about, but this is the second time I have ordered this hoping I was remembering incorrectly. Customer Care Response: We're sorry this wasn't a fit for you; you are welcome to check out Paula's suggestions at Beautypedia to see if you find another concealer that works better for you. In the meantime we will leave an in house credit for the product on your account which may be used on a future phone order. Please contact customer care so that we may locate your account in order to offer you a credit.

I love this concealer and I've tried them all. It has the coverage but not the thickness to look cakey, and not the liquidity to create creases. I've been using the same one every day for a year now and I love it (not sure why so many reviewers think there's not enough there). I have serious dark circles due to genetics and iron deficiency - I do find if you put on too much it looks unnatural and then possibly cakey. I tap small amounts around the eyes and it works (also a touch at the outsides of eyes brightens up and lifts!). There are probably comparable concealers but not at this price. Thanks Paula.

This product just didn't work for me. Don't know if I purchased the wrong shade or not, but I couldn't get it to blend without looking like a mask. Disappointed with it because I love some of Paula's other products. Customer Care Response: We're sorry this wasn't a fit for you; you are welcome to check out Paula's suggestions at Beautypedia to see if you find another concealer that works better for you. In the meantime we will leave an in house credit for the product on your account which may be used on a future phone order. Please contact customer care with any questions, we are happy to help.

I wanted to love it because I have acne marks, but the soft ivory concealer is yellow on my skin and settles into the very fine lines below my eyes. Customer Care Response: Thank you for your review. We will certainly pass along your comments and feedback about the texture and color to Paula! Feel free to check out other concealer options at: www.beautypedia.com. In the meantime we have left the purchase price of this product on your account to be used on a future phone order. Please contact customer care with any questions.

I love this concealer and have used it for years. Now I use it as my foundation. I start with one of the serums (Resist now), then lightly dab some concealer on, concentrating on places that need special coverage. The I lighty smooth the rest across the face. Since the serum is silky, the concealer covers evenly. Then pat on some powder and you're ready to go. Great stuff.

I really enjoyed using this concealer. I apply it over my foudation on any areas that need extra help, like my undereyes and any acne scars,and set everything with powder. I've not run across any other concealer that is so BLENDABLE. It just goes on like silk, and remains completely invisible as it does what it is meant to do-conceal. It's whisper-light, a pleasure to use. Thanks Paula!

This looks like a great option to try for dark under eye circles, as my current foundation doesn't fully cover under-eye dark circles. Is there a way that samples can be offered so I can tell which shade I need? I think I know which color I need, but I'm not too sure. Thanks for your time in reading this.....Customer Care Response: At this time we don't carry samples of our concealer but do offer a 60 money back guarantee in case the product does not work well for you. We will pass along your suggestions to our Product Development Manager. Please contact customer care with any questions.

This does exactly what it is supposed to do, conceals flaws, dark circles etc. Not greasy or drying goes on nicely.