(based on 128 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Reviewed by 128 customers
Displaying reviews 21-30
Back to top
« Previous | Next »
(8 of 9 customers found this review helpful)
Breaks me out
By Emma B
Comments about Earth Sourced Toner - 5 oz:
I wanted to love this as I like thicker toners that I can apply with my finger tips instead of always using a cotton pad and like the idea of extra anti-oxidants and lightweight hydration- but I've used this on and off for months now and every time end up with little pimples all over. I've tried it enough times now to be pretty certain it is the culprit as it always happens within 2-3 days of resuming use of it.
Customer Service Response: Hello, and thank you for your comments - we're sorry to hear this didn't work as expected for you! Please contact a member of our Customer Care team for information about a possible exchange or refund.
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
(10 of 13 customers found this review helpful)
Use as an antioxidant
I don't use this as a conventional toner. I use it as an antioxidant product because the serums are just too pricey for me right now. I add a few drops of the C15 to a few drops of this and dab onto my fave after toning and the 1% BHA gel. It feels great and does not make me break out. My skin is aging but breakout prone, although I have not broken out in years due to a combination of birth-control pills and PC products, which are brilliant.
(5 of 8 customers found this review helpful)
By John D.
I rated this 5 stars because the first couple of times I used it I loved it. I didn't need a cotton pad with it and it had loads of amazing ingredients, and the best thing was is that it didn't break me out. After one week of consistent use my face got extremely red and irritated. I did not use it for 3 days and my skin went back to normal. So I decided to use it again after those three days to make sure this was the culprit, and it was. I cant pinpoint which ingredient did it though.
Customer Service Response: We're sorry you� had a bad experience with this toner. Please contact us to arrange for a refund or exchange.
(2 of 3 customers found this review helpful)
Post acne red marks and redness goodbye
By John D
LOVE THIS!!!! It has a slightly thicker consistency than the rest of her toners, and I love the feeling of it, and it absorbs very quickly. I have extremely acne prone skin so I was wary of trying this because some people got acne like symptoms from it, but I did not have a reaction. It repaired my skin and quickly helped to fade my discoloration from acne. It was slightly hydrating, and did not sting my face when I used it. I absolutely love the ingredients in this. I will buy the full product.
One of Best PC Products!
By Victoria P
I have used the Earth Source cleanser and toner for about 6 months now, and I think they are wonderful products. The cleanser removes all of my makeup and is great with my clarisonic at bedtime. I use the toner as my combination toner/serum/moisturizer because I have very oily, acne prone, sensitive skin; and this product mixed with the C15 twice a day has made my skin the best it has EVER been in my life (and I am 62). And the best part is they are also very reasonably priced!
(2 of 8 customers found this review helpful)
By Elise I.
I think I'm used to toners having alcohol and being more liquidy but I think Paula's Choice toner's are more of a lotion which I'm just not used to. Because of this you need way more on the cotton ball or pad to feel like you are really getting enough on your skin. I didn't see any adverse effects from using this for a week so no complaints I just didn't see anything spectacular that would make me want to buy the full size. But there are no scary ingredients or alcohol so that's good!
(2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
Can Antioxidants give you breakouts?
By VERONICA S.
I've used PC antioxidant serums in the past, and I'd always break out. But since Paula highly recommends antioxidants and customers are always saying it brings your skin to the "next level", I thought I'd try the toner. It feels lovely and I really liked it but after about a month my skin was so clogged it was disgusting. It's been about a month since quitting and I'm finally close to normal. I usually only get inflammatory acne so the clogging was unbearable. Really wanted this to work :(
Customer Service Response: We're so sorry this toner didn't work for you. To answer your question though, antioxidants, especially in aqueous or extract form, are highly unlikely to clog pores.
(6 of 6 customers found this review helpful)
By Andrew L.
Best toner I've ever tried. Really soothing after shaving or when my skin feels a little dry. I love putting it on in the morning underneath a moisturizer + sunscreen. My skin looks really healthy and feels moisturized thanks to this product. I would say for those with really oily skin or really dry skin to try another product, simply because of the texture of this one. For every other skin type this is an amazing buy. Great value for an amazing toner.
(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
Not moisturizing enough for dry skin, made me break out
By ren y.
The texture is nice and it applies and dries easily. Unfortunately it did not help my dry flaky skin at all and I got 6 new pimples the 2 days I was using it. There are so many plant extracts that I can't be sure which one caused my breakout. For reference I usually get 3-4 pimples a month and I haven't gotten a single new one since I stopped using this.
Customer Service Response: Thanks for your review! We suspect the pimples you observed weren't true breakouts (these take weeks to form and show on the surface) but rather an irritant dermatitis, which is a type of reaction that comes on suddenly and, confusingly, can resemble breakouts. You may be allergic to one or more of the natural ingredients in this toner. We're happy to help you select another toner or provide a refund; just contact us and we'll work it out!
(2 of 4 customers found this review helpful)
Overnight relief from peeling irritated skin!
By DEBI S.
My skin was peeling so badly that it looked like I was recovering from a sunburn. I didn't even want to go out in public that is how awful I felt. I ordered this because it said it could help with irritation and skin recovery toner wasn't helping. OMG I saw OVERNIGHT results! My skin still has a little surface dryness but the peeling is gone! I have used it for 2 days now and the results are sincerely dramatic! Now that it is on sale I am stocking up as I now can't live without! Thank you Paula!